Do broken tines affect both typical and non-typical scoring?

Typical Scoring Considerations

When scoring typical antlers, a broken tine is usually penalized. According to the Boone and Crockett Club’s scoring system, a broken tine is valued at 50% of its full potential length. This means that if a tine is broken at 12 inches long, it would be valued at 6 inches.

Non-Typical Scoring Considerations

Non-typical antlers, on the other hand, can be more subjective when it comes to broken tines. While the Boone and Crockett Club still uses the same valuation system as for typical antlers, the panel of judges may consider other factors such as the overall symmetry and balance of the antlers, as well as the potential for the broken tine to have grown longer with time. However, non-typical antlers are often more forgiving when it comes to broken tines, as the unique characteristics of these antlers can sometimes make a broken tine less noticeable.

Measuring Broken Tines

When measuring a broken tine, it’s essential to measure the length of the remaining portion of the tine as accurately as possible. This can be done using a calibrated measuring tape or a digital caliper. It’s also crucial to keep in mind that the Boone and Crockett Club requires a minimum of 16 inches of main beam length from the base of the antlers to the tip of the main beam to qualify for scoring.