Can using a heavier broadhead improve penetration on tough hides?

Choosing the Right Broadhead for Tough Hides

When hunting large game with tough hides, penetration is crucial. A heavier broadhead may seem like the obvious choice, but it’s not always the case. Fixed broadheads, for example, typically have a heavier weight and a larger cutting diameter. A 125-grain or heavier fixed broadhead with a 1.5-inch cutting diameter may penetrate deeper into the hide, but its flight characteristics may suffer. This could result in a lower arrow speed and less accuracy.

Broadhead Types and Their Performance

Mechanical broadheads, on the other hand, are designed to open quickly upon impact, creating a larger wound channel. These broadheads often have a smaller cutting diameter, around 1 inch, but their weight can vary. A 100-grain mechanical broadhead with a high G-force rating may perform well on tough hides, especially when paired with a 300-grain arrow. Hybrid broadheads, which combine features from fixed and mechanical designs, may offer the best of both worlds. A 120-grain hybrid broadhead with a 1.25-inch cutting diameter and a G-force rating of 200 may provide excellent penetration and expansion.

Game-Specific Choice

The choice of broadhead ultimately depends on the type of game being hunted. For larger game like elk or moose, a heavier broadhead with a larger cutting diameter may be necessary. However, for smaller game like deer, a lighter broadhead with a smaller cutting diameter may be more effective. Understanding the game’s body structure and the type of hide it has can help hunters make an informed decision. Additionally, practicing with different broadheads and arrows can help hunters fine-tune their skills and choose the best equipment for their needs.