Quick Answer
A .357 Sig might be a viable option for deer hunting, but it's essential to consider factors like effective range, bullet weight, and kinetic energy. While it can be effective at close to medium ranges, it may not be the best choice for longer shots or larger deer.
Caliber Considerations
When it comes to handgun hunting for deer, caliber selection is crucial. A .357 Sig, while potent, typically produces around 550-600 ft-lbs of kinetic energy with a 125-grain bullet. This is comparable to the 44 Magnum, which averages around 600-700 ft-lbs with the same weight. However, the 44 Magnum tends to have more kinetic energy due to its higher muzzle velocity and larger case size. On the other hand, the 10mm Auto typically delivers around 700-800 ft-lbs of kinetic energy, making it a more suitable choice for larger deer.
Effective Range and Bullet Weight
For deer hunting, it’s generally recommended to use a bullet with a minimum weight of 140 grains and a velocity of at least 1,000 ft/s. Within this range, a .357 Sig can be effective out to around 100 yards, but its effectiveness diminishes beyond 125 yards. To improve accuracy and penetration, consider using a heavier bullet, such as the 150-168 grain variety, which will maintain its kinetic energy and expand consistently at longer ranges.
Revolver vs Semi-Auto
When choosing between a revolver and semi-automatic handgun for deer hunting, consider the reliability and smoothness of operation under stress. Revolvers, with their simplistic design, tend to be more reliable and less prone to jamming. However, semi-automatics, like the Glock 20, can offer faster follow-up shots and reduced recoil. Ultimately, the choice between a revolver and semi-auto depends on personal preference and the specific hunting scenario.
Find more answers
Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.